It's time for me to change transmission fluid in my civic si-r (standard
transmission). Of course the honda manual says i must get honda
transmission fluid. Apparently there is special additives in this fluid so
you shouldn't use 10-30w oil. If I don't want to go with overpriced honda
product, what's a good equilevant?

 

you didn't mention the year of your vehicle, but the fluid sells for $7 a
litre (canadian) and you need 2 litres. The fluid lasts for 50000kms or so,
why the hell would you chince out on this? Thats a little less than $0.0003
per km.

Jeremy wrote:
>It's time for me to change transmission fluid in my civic si-r (standard
>transmission). Of course the honda manual says i must get honda
>transmission fluid. Apparently there is special additives in this fluid so
>you shouldn't use 10-30w oil. If I don't want to go with overpriced honda
>product, what's a good equilevant?


--
Message posted via http://www.carkb.com

 

This comes up every so often here. I assume you have an older Civic
(mid-1990s or younger), and the owner's manual says to use 10W-30. You can
google, but I'm pretty sure you'll find support for the Honda tranny fluid
being superior to the 10W-30, both operationally and also as far as
maximizing the life of the gears etc. I am told one will actually feel the
difference in shifting. IIRC, modern 10W-30 doesn't contain the additives
that older 10W-30 had.

The next time my 1991 Civic (170k miles) needs a manual transmission fluid
change, I am going to try, for the first time ever, the Honda fluid. Like TL
said, I think the expense is low enough to at least give it a try.

"Jeremy" <jeremychapman@shaw.ca> wrote
> It's time for me to change transmission fluid in my civic si-r (standard
> transmission). Of course the honda manual says i must get honda
> transmission fluid. Apparently there is special additives in this fluid
so
> you shouldn't use 10-30w oil. If I don't want to go with overpriced honda
> product, what's a good equilevant?
>
>

 

"Elle" <elle_navorski@nospam.earthlink.net> wrote
> This comes up every so often here. I assume you have an older Civic
> (mid-1990s or younger),

Post-o. Change "younger" to "older."

Some discussion of the subject of switching from 10W-30 to Honda Tranny
fluid (saying pretty much what I posted):

http://www.honda-acura.net/forums/sh...3503f004766755
ec49909&p=2499959#post2499959


From a post of mine in July:

The only authoritative
citation on the subject appears to be from George M., who wrote that "the
Honda Australia site started to push Honda lubricants fairly recently and
now recommend Honda MTF for manual gearboxes; prior to that they used to
recommend a SAE 75W-80 API GL4 lubricant."

The only thing I found at the Australia site so far is at
http://www.honda.com.au/buying+a+honda/parts/ , which says: "Honda MTF Plus
Manual Transmission Fluid has been specifically formulated for use in all
Honda manual transmissions. MTF Plus is designed to provide smoother
shifting operation at all temperatures over the life of the fluid."

Googling yields comments like that at
http://www.inlinefour.com/honmantranfl.html . I am finding nothing
dispositive on the subject, so far.

 

"Elle" <elle_navorski@nospam.earthlink.net> wrote in
newsImXe.67$zQ3.38@newsread1.news.pas.earthlink. net:

> "Elle" <elle_navorski@nospam.earthlink.net> wrote
>> This comes up every so often here. I assume you have an older Civic
>> (mid-1990s or younger),
>
> Post-o. Change "younger" to "older."
>
> Some discussion of the subject of switching from 10W-30 to Honda
> Tranny fluid (saying pretty much what I posted)



<snip>



The primary impetus for the preference of Honda MTL is the change in
composition of 10W-30 since it was first recommended by Honda.

The anti-wear additives in 10W-30 motor oil (specifically zinc and sulphur)
have been reduced in the interest of protecting the catalytic converter.
Since the tranny has no cat, you can put as much anti-wear additive as you
need, hence the formulation of Honda MTL. Ever notice how it stinks?

Basically, Honda's old recommendation is outmoded.

And to the OP: Yes MTL is expensive, but it's still only about $10 per
quart. Have you ever priced tranny rebuilds? Or even a used transmission?
MTL is pretty cheap in comparison.

Cheaping out here is /definitely/ false economy.

--
TeGGeR®

The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/

 

"Jeremy" <jeremychapman@shaw.ca> wrote in message
news:AsiXe.219904$Hk.167493@pd7tw1no...
> It's time for me to change transmission fluid in my civic si-r (standard
> transmission). Of course the honda manual says i must get honda
> transmission fluid. Apparently there is special additives in this fluid
> so
> you shouldn't use 10-30w oil. If I don't want to go with overpriced honda
> product, what's a good equilevant?
>
Stick with Honda MTF. I've done a lot of research on this subject and the
only other fluid I would use would be GM's friction modified synchroshift
fluid which can only be gotten at a GM dealer and at the cost of $20 per
quart, makes Honda MTF look like a bargain.

 

Jeremy wrote:
> It's time for me to change transmission fluid in my civic si-r (standard
> transmission). Of course the honda manual says i must get honda
> transmission fluid. Apparently there is special additives in this fluid so
> you shouldn't use 10-30w oil. If I don't want to go with overpriced honda
> product, what's a good equilevant?
>
>

Valvoline claims that their Maxlife transmission fluid is Honda
compatible. Nobody sells an aftermarket fluid certified to Honda specs
because Honda keeps the specs secret.

John

 

John Horner wrote:
> Jeremy wrote:
>
>> It's time for me to change transmission fluid in my civic si-r (standard
>> transmission). Of course the honda manual says i must get honda
>> transmission fluid. Apparently there is special additives in this
>> fluid so
>> you shouldn't use 10-30w oil. If I don't want to go with overpriced
>> honda
>> product, what's a good equilevant?
>>
>>
>
> Valvoline claims that their Maxlife transmission fluid is Honda
> compatible. Nobody sells an aftermarket fluid certified to Honda specs
> because Honda keeps the specs secret.
>
> John

Sorry, my mistake in not reading your manual transmission requirement
carefully.

One very popular replacement fluid for manual transmission which call
for a 10W-30 style fluid is Redline Synthetic MTL. It isn't cheap, but
it is really good stuff.

John