2006 Civic Faulty Radios
#16
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
I had my front windshield replaced (stress crack from the cold) in my
civic by honda and have never had a problem with leaks or anything.
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
> Kevin wrote:
> > Chi-town Civic wrote:
> >
> > > Have you checked the antenna input wire in the back of the reciever?
> >
> > Yes I believe that was the first thing the dealership checked.
> > They also said they could not "recreate" the reception and volume
> > problems.
> > Because my dealership replaced other customer's window for a similar
> > complaint and they said that fixed it, the dealership is stuck on
> > telling me that is all they are willing to try and do next for my
> > complaint.
> > Sorry, I should have mentioned that.
> > Thanks. K.
civic by honda and have never had a problem with leaks or anything.
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
> Kevin wrote:
> > Chi-town Civic wrote:
> >
> > > Have you checked the antenna input wire in the back of the reciever?
> >
> > Yes I believe that was the first thing the dealership checked.
> > They also said they could not "recreate" the reception and volume
> > problems.
> > Because my dealership replaced other customer's window for a similar
> > complaint and they said that fixed it, the dealership is stuck on
> > telling me that is all they are willing to try and do next for my
> > complaint.
> > Sorry, I should have mentioned that.
> > Thanks. K.
#17
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
I had my front windshield replaced (stress crack from the cold) in my
civic by honda and have never had a problem with leaks or anything.
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
> Kevin wrote:
> > Chi-town Civic wrote:
> >
> > > Have you checked the antenna input wire in the back of the reciever?
> >
> > Yes I believe that was the first thing the dealership checked.
> > They also said they could not "recreate" the reception and volume
> > problems.
> > Because my dealership replaced other customer's window for a similar
> > complaint and they said that fixed it, the dealership is stuck on
> > telling me that is all they are willing to try and do next for my
> > complaint.
> > Sorry, I should have mentioned that.
> > Thanks. K.
civic by honda and have never had a problem with leaks or anything.
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
> Kevin wrote:
> > Chi-town Civic wrote:
> >
> > > Have you checked the antenna input wire in the back of the reciever?
> >
> > Yes I believe that was the first thing the dealership checked.
> > They also said they could not "recreate" the reception and volume
> > problems.
> > Because my dealership replaced other customer's window for a similar
> > complaint and they said that fixed it, the dealership is stuck on
> > telling me that is all they are willing to try and do next for my
> > complaint.
> > Sorry, I should have mentioned that.
> > Thanks. K.
#18
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
believe it will solve the problem.
I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
Thanks. K.
#19
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
believe it will solve the problem.
I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
Thanks. K.
#20
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
believe it will solve the problem.
I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
Thanks. K.
#21
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Chi-town Civic wrote:
> As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
> let them do it
I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
believe it will solve the problem.
I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
Thanks. K.
#22
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Kevin wrote:
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#23
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Kevin wrote:
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#24
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Kevin wrote:
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#25
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Kevin wrote:
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>
>
>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>let them do it
>
>
> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
> believe it will solve the problem.
> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
> Thanks. K.
>
I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
reception. FM is fine.
Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that
way you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree
with you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it
was going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it
increases the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#26
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Good idea but he says dealer cannot duplicate poor reception so it might not
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#27
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Good idea but he says dealer cannot duplicate poor reception so it might not
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#28
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Good idea but he says dealer cannot duplicate poor reception so it might not
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#29
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Good idea but he says dealer cannot duplicate poor reception so it might not
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
work.
"na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
> Kevin wrote:
>> Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>
>>
>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>let them do it
>>
>>
>> I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>> believe it will solve the problem.
>> I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>> problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>> you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>> Thanks. K.
>>
> I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
> reception. FM is fine.
>
> Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
> taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
> window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
> put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
> you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
> you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
> going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
> the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
#30
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: 2006 Civic Faulty Radios
Art wrote:
> Good idea but he says dealer cannot duplicate poor reception so it might not
> work.
>
>
> "na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
> news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
>
>>Kevin wrote:
>>
>>>Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>>let them do it
>>>
>>>
>>>I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>>>believe it will solve the problem.
>>>I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>>>problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>>>you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>>>Thanks. K.
>>>
>>
>>I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
>>reception. FM is fine.
>>
>>Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
>>taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
>>window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
>>put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
>>you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
>>you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
>>going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
>>the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
>
>
I'm surpised then that they would even offer to replace the window.
Usually they're pretty stuborn about having to "verify" the customer's
complaint before swapping parts.
> Good idea but he says dealer cannot duplicate poor reception so it might not
> work.
>
>
> "na" <bkc93@comcast.net> wrote in message
> news:sZidncnZkuVrunPZnZ2dnUVZ_vadnZ2d@comcast.com. ..
>
>>Kevin wrote:
>>
>>>Chi-town Civic wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>>As long as you're not footin the bill for them to replace the window,
>>>>let them do it
>>>
>>>
>>>I know what you mean, but it seems so drastic, I find it hard to
>>>believe it will solve the problem.
>>>I have had exterior warranty repairs in the past that have caused more
>>>problems than the first one, (shhh... it was a new "Saturn" sedan mind
>>>you) so I am a little gun shy about the window approach.
>>>Thanks. K.
>>>
>>
>>I have a simlar problem with my 2006 Civic, but it only affects the AM
>>reception. FM is fine.
>>
>>Here's what you should ask them to do: order the new window but before
>>taking out the old one, have them connect the antenna wire to the new
>>window and see if that improves the reception. If not, tell them not to
>>put it in and to continue looking for the real problem. At least that way
>>you don't have them taking the old one out for no reason. I agree with
>>you. I wouldn't want them doing such a "repair" unless I knew it was
>>going to fix the problem. When the dealers mess with a car, it increases
>>the chance of something wrong, i.e. they screw something up.
>
>
I'm surpised then that they would even offer to replace the window.
Usually they're pretty stuborn about having to "verify" the customer's
complaint before swapping parts.